Does Methadone Maintenance Treatment Affect Heart Health?By Stewart B. Leavitt, PhD, Editor OverviewMany factors can upset normal heart rhythm, provoking disturbances known as cardiac arrhythmias. Recent warnings about LAAM in that regard also raised questions about whether methadone might influence cardiac adverse events. Persons coming into methadone maintenance treatment (MMT) programs typically have multiple risk factors for heart illness, starting with their abuses of potentially cardiotoxic substances, such as heroin, cocaine, alcohol, and tobacco. Many patients also have physical illness that may contribute to heart problems. And, the variety of medications often prescribed for these patients, in addition to methadone, may interact to produce certain cardiac electrical conduction disturbances. Medical researchers continue to explore factors that may alter cardiac electrical conduction processes to cause arrhythmias. Laboratory studies have demonstrated an effect of methadone on cardiac electrical conduction, but such approaches have limitations and their relevance for patients in MMT programs is questionable. Assessing risks of potential heart problems in MMT patients must take into account diverse factors. At present, based on more than 35 years of accumulated scientific research and its safety record in millions of patients, methadone itself does not appear to have clinically harmful effects on heart health. This report summarizes the conclusions of evidence-based research and the published commentary of experts in the field to provide a current and balanced perspective. Some suggested action steps for MMT clinics are provided. Heightened ConcernIs oral methadone, as used in methadone maintenance treatment (MMT) for opioid addiction, possibly associated with disturbances of heart rhythm, called cardiac arrhythmias? This question was prompted by several events. In Spring 2001, the European Agency for the Evaluation of Medicinal Products (EMEA) withdrew LAAM (levacetylmethadol or Orlaam®) from the market due to reported adverse cardiac events.1 At the same time, the United States Food and Drug Administration strengthened warnings about potential cardiac problems associated with LAAM and highlighted them in a black box on product labeling.2 These directives were based on a relatively small number of patients who were taking LAAM and experienced serious cardiac electrical conduction disturbances known as Long QT Syndrome and Torsade de Pointes. Although LAAM differs from methadone by its longer-term action and metabolites, there was speculation that methadone also might influence such heart problems.1 Further interest was stimulated by laboratory research from a team at Georgetown University, reporting methadone effects on certain electrical currents in the heart.3 Is methadone harmful, helpful, or neutral when it comes to heart health? This question must be considered in the light of scientific evidence and also take into account the special population of patients in MMT programs. Heart Rhythm & ArrhythmiaElectrical currents regulate heart rhythm in an orderly and time-sensitive fashion. Disruption of electrical conduction processes can lead to life-threatening arrhythmias. ECGs Tell The Tale. An electrocardiograph (ECG) measures electrical current moving through the heart during each heartbeat, and an important portion of the characteristic waveform is the QT interval. See figure. It represents the time period from when the heart ventricles discharge electrical energy and contract (called depolarization) to when the ventricles become recharged and ready again to pump blood through the body (repolarization). These processes are controlled by electrically-charged calcium, sodium, and potassium ions.4-7 (See sidebar for further details.) The QT interval, measured in fractions of a second or milliseconds (msec), is a vital indicator of healthy heart function. Prolongation of the QT interval to greater than normal length has been considered a sign of potential arrhythmia.6-8 Measuring QT. Heart rate affects QT length; for example, it becomes shorter as the heart speeds up. Therefore, the QT interval is usually corrected for heart rate and expressed as QTc (QT-corrected),9 so comparisons can be made independent of heart rate. (Also see sidebar.) There are several obstacles to accurately and reliably measuring QTc intervals, and there are numerous individual factors that may influence a particular person's QTc length. For example, women generally have longer QTc intervals than men.10-12 This diversity of factors can make it difficult to interpret the significance of suspected QTc lengthening in individual patients. Defining "Prolonged" QT. How long can the QT interval become before there is a risk of heart problems? The EMEA1,13 and others5,6,11,14-17 have suggested that QTc-interval values of 500 msec or more, or increases of greater than 601,13 to 7511,16 msec from baseline, could be considered abnormal and indicate risk of arrhythmia. It has been suggested that the upper limits of normal QTc-interval values are greater than usually acknowledged8,15 and might range from 420 to 500 msec.17 Yet, many studies have used that range to indicate abnormal QTc lengthening, reporting 8% to 23% of patients at risk for arrhythmia.8 Thus, premature alarms may have been sounded in many cases. Long QT Syndrome (LQTS). A consistent, persistent, and abnormally prolonged QTc interval is referred to as Long QT Syndrome or LQTS. It can be an inherited condition, called congenital LQTS, involving defects in genes that control electrical conduction channels in heart muscle.18 LQTS also may be caused by certain drugs or toxins, abnormal levels of electrolytes (e.g., potassium, calcium, or magnesium), or certain physical ailments. This is known as acquired LQTS.18 As a syndrome, there may be multiple aspects of LQTS. If the heart muscle recharging process (repolarization) is extremely delayed, such as by drugs that block electrical currents, it can greatly slow normal heartbeat, which may influence arrhythmia. Or, the ventricles may fire before they are fully recharged, producing weak contractions.15,18
During a TdP episode, often brought on by exercise or sudden stress, the person may experience palpitations, dizziness, or lightheadedness. In more extreme cases, the person may faint (called syncope) or have what appears as a seizure due to insufficient blood flow to the brain.15,21 TdP can resolve on its own, with a return to more regular heart rhythm and the person recovering. However, further TdP episodes may quickly follow and possibly degenerate into ventricular fibrillation (convulsive twitching), causing death if the person is not resuscitated.21 A Closer Look at ArrhythmiaAfter accumulated electrical energy reaches a sufficient level in the ventricles, calcium (Ca) and sodium (Na) ions flow into muscle cells, serving as a discharging "trigger" mechanism. This depolarization process reaches a peak at the R position of the ECG waveform, causing the ventricles to contract.6,7 See figure. Ventricular recharging primarily involves a flow of potassium ions (K) out of heart muscle cells. At least 7 different types of potassium ion channels have been identified, and the channel most often involved in acquired LQTS is called the rapid component of the delayed rectifier potassium current. This repolarization process extends to the end of the recovery T wave.6,7,22 The QT interval is most commonly corrected for heart rate using BazettÕs formula: QTc = QT interval divided by the square root of the preceding RR interval. However, accurate measurement of QT on the ECG rhythm strip is complicated by a lack of standardization in ECG recorders, subtle changes in waveforms, and differences in interpreting readings.10,11,13-15 Furthermore, individual patient differences may affect QT length: e.g., abnormal electrolyte levels, physical illness, and drug or alcohol consumption,6,23 shift work or time of day the ECG reading is taken,24,25 postural changes during ECG recording,26 and even a full stomach.27 Calculated QTc intervals may be 10% longer in women until age 50, when the QTc in men lengthens to equal that of women.12,18 It should be noted that several authors have proposed that there actually is no "cutoff" level for QTc prolongation that clearly predicts the induction of cardiac arrhythmia or TdP. Also, the relationship between QTc and TdP in general is poorly defined, although women, with longer QTc intervals, are most prone to developing TdP. Many risk factors for developing heart rhythm disturbances other than the QTc interval may be more important.8,12,15-18,2 Risk Factors in MMT Patients.Although there can be a strong hereditary influence in developing life-threatening LQTS and/or TdP, it is believed that acquired forms due to physical illness or drugs are much more common. Many risk factors for cardiac arrhythmia are typically present in MMT patient populations. LQTS Prevalence. In general, cardiac arrhythmias may account for more than 10% of all natural deaths.4 There are 300,000 to 400,000 sudden cardiac deaths each year in the U.S., with most due to ventricular arrhythmia.4,21 An estimated 7000 to 8000 of those deaths are in young persons, with LQTS accounting for roughly half of them.4,21,29 LQTS occurs in all races and ethnic groups, and may be more common than presently imagined. An investigation in one medical center found a 7% prevalence of LQTS in more than 34,000 patients undergoing ECG screening during a 6-month period.30 A genetic tendency for LQTS may exist in about 1 in 5000 persons, or roughly 50,000 in the U.S. and more than 200,000 worldwide.4,21,29 The death rate for patients with inherited LQTS has been estimated at 1% to 2% per year.20 An important indicator of inherited risk for persons coming into MMT programs would be a history of blood relatives who experienced sudden cardiac death. Substance Abuse. Besides opioid dependency, a high prevalence of other substance abuse would be expected in persons entering MMT, including: cocaine, alcohol, tobacco, and marijuana.31 Cocaine has long been recognized as toxic to the heart, slowing sodium channels and depressing heart rhythm,7 and possibly causing heart attack.32 The QTc may be prolonged in 17%33 to 19%34 of patients who abuse alcohol and a third of those may experience rapid heartbeat.33 Tobacco smoking has long been known as a heart attack risk, and a recent report also has implicated marijuana smoking.35 In a long-term study of heroin addicts, the death rate due to cardiovascular diseases was 12%.31 Early studies found that 61%36 to 84%37 of heroin addicts had adverse changes in their ECG waveforms. One study of persons entering an MMT program noted that 31% exhibited QTc prolongation.36 Taken together, the findings suggest that a significant proportion of patients entering MMT might be expected to have irregularities in their ECG waveforms. These might consist predominantly of longer QTc intervals than would be found in the general population. Physical Illness. A number of physical illnesses are associated with prolongation of the QTc interval, including: anorexia, cardiovascular disease, endocrine abnormalities, central nervous system disorders, diabetes, electrolyte disturbances, HIV, liver disease, obesity, and others.8,17 Thus, many patients in MMT programs could be at risk due to these conditions. Medications. Medications account for most cases of acquired LQTS that can induce TdP.17,38 Many patients in MMT programs are treated with multiple drugs that may alter electrical conduction in heart muscle tissues.7,10,19,21,22 Patients with preexisting heart conditions may be receiving cardiovascular drugs. Many of these, especially those with antiarrhythmic properties, affect ion channels and electrical conduction currents, and their misuse or combination with interacting medications can result in adverse events.7 Most conventional and some newer atypical antipsychotic agents have been associated with drug-induced QTc lengthening and potential arrhythmias.8,17,39 Also, the tetra- and tricyclic, and some SSRI, antidepressants may provoke adverse cardiac reactions.8,17,21 Experience over the years has demonstrated that many other noncardiac drugs sometimes used in MMT patients also may influence LQTS and/or TdP.21,40 See chart. |
|||
|
|
|||
| amitriptyline [Elavil] | lithium [Lithonate] | ||
| ampicillin [Omnipen] | olanzapine [Zyprexa]** | ||
| carbamazepine [Tegretol] | prochlorperazine [Compazine] | ||
| clarithromycin [Biaxin] | quetiapine [Seroquel]** | ||
| doxepin [Sinequan] | risperidone [Risperdal] | ||
| erythromycin [Ery-Tab] | sparfloxacin [Zagam]** | ||
| fexofenadine [Allegra]** | sumatriptan [Imitrex] | ||
| fluoxetine [Prozac]** | TMP/SMX [Bactrim] | ||
| haloperidol [Haldol] | tamoxifen [Nolvadex] | ||
| imipramine [Tofranil] | tetracycline [Sumycin] | ||
| ketoconazole [Nizoral] | venlafaxine [Effexor] | ||
| levofloxacin [Levaquin]** | |||
| *Partial list based on selections from the most prescribed drugs in the U.S.,Sigler & Flanders, Inc., 2000. | |||
| **Potentially minor effects at recommended therapeutic doses. | |||
| [Brand names are registered trademarks of the respective manufacturers.] | |||
|
Lengthening of the QT interval can be an important precursor to TdP; however, not all drugs that prolong the QT also cause TdP. Furthermore, TdP may be caused by drugs having no prior effect on the QT interval.15 Drug Interactions. Interactions during administration of multiple drugs can be a critical risk factor for LQTS and TdP.3,5,19,22 It has been observed that nearly three-quarters of all adverse events associated with methadone, including those affecting cardiac function, involve comedications.41 Simultaneous use of drugs that compete for or inhibit liver enzymes needed for metabolism may result in elevated concentrations of agents that could induce arrhythmia.3,5,19,22,39 Methadone, being variously metabolized by up to 5 liver enzymes, may interact with many other medications and result in accumulations of those agents.42,43 One study found that roughly 38% of 206 psychiatric patients with a prolonged QTc (defined conservatively as greater than 420 msec) were on methadone. However, virtually all of the methadone patients also received one or more antipsychotic medicines that might have affected cardiac electrical conduction.34 Furthermore, it has been proposed that some persons, perhaps more than commonly assumed, may be silent gene carriers for LQTS. Such persons are at genetically increased risk from certain medications and are more prone to develop drug-induced arrhythmias than patients who receive the same drug(s) safely.44 However, it has been suggested that use of drugs known to prolong QTc is not necessarily harmful, unless: a) the drug is administered rapidly and directly into the system (e.g., IV injection), b) concomitant metabolic inhibitors are used, and/or c) other risk factors exist. Even in these circumstances, it is difficult to determine an upper threshold for prolongation of the QTc interval that predicts development of TdP or other arrhythmia.10 There is an ongoing need to assess risk-benefit relationships of multidrug administration in MMT patients. As one researcher noted, "disparate factors ranging from inappropriate multidrug therapy to a glass of grapefruit juice can render the heart of any patient susceptible to ventricular arrhythmias." Physicians should become more knowledgeable regarding drug interactions and cardiac risk factors so they might prevent adverse situations before they occur.22 Research ObservationsResults of laboratory investigations into methadone's influence on cardiac electrical conduction have been conflicting, and some might be interpreted as implying cardiac benefits of methadone. Clinical studies in MMT patients specifically focusing on cardiac issues have been limited. Laboratory Investigations. A team at Georgetown University recently reported that methadone diminished potassium ion flow and reduced repolarization currents by half their maximal strength in human heart-cell cultures.3 However, it is not known what this might mean clinically and the effect was seen at methadone blood concentrations nearly 9 times greater than usual therapeutic levels recommended for MMT patients.43 Earlier laboratory research had demonstrated similar effects. In sheep heart cells, methadone at very high concentrations delayed electrical conduction.45 In squid and chick cells, methadone slowed potassium and, to a lesser degree, sodium and calcium electrical currents across cell membranes.46 This effect also was demonstrated by reduced swimming speed in protozoa,47 and the slowing was more than doubled by the addition of alcohol.48 In guinea-pig45 and cat49 heart muscle, methadone strengthened contractile force (called inotropic effect), which might be beneficial in some patients. However, at very high doses, 10 times peak toxic concentrations in humans, methadone produced an apparent reduction in electrical excitability in cat heart-muscle cells accompanied by a negative inotropic effect - that is, it weakened contractility.50 This effect also was observed in rat tissues51 and appears related to methadone's ability to retard inward calcium currents.45,51-53 It should be noted that laboratory research in cell cultures or animals does not necessarily translate into clinical significance in patients. Laboratory investigations allow studying pure drug effects at known concentrations;5 however, they do not take into account the idiosyncrasies of metabolism and cardiac function in humans.5,10,54 Differences in animal metabolism and response, and the experimental methods employed, have resulted in inconsistent reports of methadone's effects on electrical conduction.50,55 Furthermore, methadone was usually applied directly to heart tissues on a single-dose basis and at high concentrations, rather than simulating daily doses achieving steady-state blood serum levels that typify MMT.54 Also, methadone concentrations in human heart muscle are unknown and may be lower than those present in blood serum.10 Cardiac Advantages?. Effects on cardiac electrical conduction do not automatically imply harmful consequences, and actually may be a sign of a drug's usefulness as a heart medication.19 Over the years, certain opioids, including methadone, have demonstrated cardioprotective effects and have been important adjuncts in treating heart attacks and coronary artery disease.32,50 Also, as noted above, methadone appears to reduce calcium flow into heart tissues. It has been suggested that decreases in intracellular calcium may protect the heart from calcium overload during stress reactions. Furthermore, research in rats demonstrated that cocaine-related myocardial infarction could be prevented by blocking calcium channels, and experiments in mice found that opioids helped protect the heart from adverse cocaine effects.56 The calcium-slowing effects of methadone may be analogous to the actions of certain heart medications that suppress some forms of arrhythmia.57 One author commented on similarities of methadone and verapamil (e.g., Calan®, Verelan®),52 a calcium-channel-blocking agent indicated for the treatment of hypertension and angina, and to prevent arrhythmia related to rapid heartbeat. It has not appeared on any lists of agents known to prolong QTc or induce TdP and, in fact, calcium-blocking action may shorten the QTc interval.7 Thus, while laboratory research suggests that methadone may influence certain ion channels and cardiac electrical conduction, those effects have not been proved harmful in humans. Some of methadone's actions demonstrated in the laboratory actually may provide a degree of cardiac protection in certain MMT patients, although this still needs to be demonstrated in clinical studies. Clinical Explorations. In one small study of MMT patients,36 66% had ECG alterations during their early tenure in the program, primarily QTc prolongations (of undefined length) in 34%, which were likely preexisting conditions. However, after 4 or more months in MMT, and abstinence from all illicit drugs and alcohol, the QTc irregularities vanished in 54% of those patients retested. Whereas, 4 patients who continued sporadic drug abuse while in MMT developed QTc prolongations that were not initially present. Recently, there have been questions about whether methadone doses higher than those typically used in many MMT programs might engender added cardiac risks and justify extra precautions.1,42 A case series from one large MMT clinic28 examined 12 patients receiving 500 mg or more of daily methadone (average 812 mg/d; range 500-1400 mg/d).See graph. All patients were taking comedications and many had physical illness, such as HIV, hepatitis, liver cirrhosis, hypertension, and diabetes; although none of the patients had signs or symptoms of heart distress.
As might be expected, females exhibited higher average QTc values than males: 460 vs 422 msec. The overall average QTc interval of 435 msec was within normal limits. Only one patient had a QTc greater than the 500 msec "abnormal threshold" - 512 msec. This was a 43-year-old woman with hepatitis C, taking several medications, and receiving 1000 mg/d of methadone. She had never experienced symptoms of heart distress and, in fact, was very athletic - an avid runner. An ECG ten years earlier, when she was receiving only 100 mg/d of methadone, had exhibited an identical QTc interval. As the graph demonstrates, there was only a moderate correlation between methadone dose and QTc interval in these patients (r = 0.53). Methadone blood serum levels were not tested, and it is likely that any potential influence on QTc might relate more to methadone blood concentrations rather than dose.42 As this study seems to confirm, it has been proposed that patients at higher methadone doses do not necessarily present greater risks of cardiotoxicity induced by methadone. However, those patients with known abnormal QTc prolongation and/or multiple cardiac risk factors might merit extra precautions.42 MMT Practice ImplicationsThere currently does not appear to be conclusive research evidence suggesting that oral methadone itself is clinically harmful to heart health.1 This is supported by methadone's successful use for the treatment of opioid dependency in millions of patients during the past 35 years. Long History of Safety. Long-term clinical studies in large populations of methadone patients have found the medication to be safe and generally without toxic effects,58-60 even though risks for cardiac complications were numerous in many patients. In one of the studies, 15% of deaths were due to tobacco-smoking-related heart disease, 20% were due to HCV, 15% were AIDS-related, and 5% were associated with morbid obesity.61 In another study, 40% of deaths were drug-abuse-related, primarily alcohol.62 Investigations of drug-related fatalities worldwide consistently have found few if any deaths directly related to methadone.61,62 Toxicity due to multidrug abuse has been the leading cause of death.41 The methadone induction phase is sometimes problematic,41,42 although 80% of deaths during this period have been attributed to mixed-drug overdose.41 This period prior to methadone stabilization could be a time of increased cardiac risk, since there might be unexpected surges in blood levels of cardioactive comedications and/or abused substances due to metabolic interactions with methadone. Steps To Consider. Sound medical practice dictates a need for continued vigilance to identify individual patient risk factors for cardiac illness. Added to these are risks that may be imposed by treatment regimens involving multiple medications - iatrogenic risk factors. The goal is to provide individualized treatment plans that preserve heart health. To help achieve this, clinics may want to adopt certain practices:
The early identification and ongoing monitoring of factors predisposing to QTc prolongation and/or TdP or other arrhythmias can be vital for heart health in MMT patients. Even if some factors, such as female gender or genetics cannot be modified, others such as electrolyte imbalances or potentially interacting medications might be easily remedied once identified. References
Addiction Treatment Forum thanks the following for their reviews of this report: Patrick Aeberhard, MD. Centre Cardiologique du Nord, St. Denis, France; Chin B. Eap, PhD, Hospital of Cery, Prilly-Lausanne, Switzerland; Mark W. Parrino, MPA, American Methadone Treatment Association, New York, NY; Edwin a. Salistz, MD, Beth Israel Medical Center, New York, NY. June 2001 | |||
| © AT Forum | Privacy/Terms of Use | Contact Us | Updated June 15, 2008 |